Aluminum vs. fiberglass screens
#1
Post
by jayhawk » Sat Nov 12, 10:07 am
XZH contains other products and information you need, so please check it out.
Looking at 21 premium vinyl windows. Current wood windows have structurally flimsy full screens that have not done well over the 20 years.
First, what's the tradeoff for full vs. half-screeens? Seems like many windows come with half-screens standard. One rep mentioned more susceptible to bugs with half-screen. Does a full screen make it look more like a wood window?
Second, what's the tradeoff for fiberglass mesh vs. aluminum screens. Apprarently upgrading to aluminum is $12 per window for Simonton . What's the likelihood of a crease in aluminum vs. hole in fiberglass? Live in Kansas City. Can have some severe weather, e.g., occasional hail storm. In general, how appealing in looks is one versus the other?
Realize this is not the biggest issue in windows but trying to button down some details. Thanks.
Re: Aluminum vs. fiberglass screens
#2
Post
by DansWindow » Sat Nov 12, 1:03 pm
I would recommend the full screen if you use your windows for fresh air. With a full screen you can open both top and bottom sashes to get a good flow of fresh air. The hot air will go out the top sash and fresh cooler air comes in at the bottom. The added benefit of the full screen is doing this without the bug getting inside.
I always felt that aluminum screens were better for ventilation due to the aluminum screen cloth having a slightly larger weave. Fiberglass has a tendency to collect dust more than aluminum which allows even less air to flow through the cloth. I also think that fiberglass can look baggy on wider window opening.
Re: Aluminum vs. fiberglass screens
#3
Post
by Windows on Washington » Sat Nov 12, 6:11 pm
Half screen:
+ more light through the top sash
- inability to vent through both sashes at the same time.
Aluminum mesh will be stronger and more resistant to tear when compared to fiberglass but aluminum screening will also oxidize over time and this is the gray film you see on most windows.
Re: Aluminum vs. fiberglass screens
#4
Post
by HomeSealed » Sat Nov 12, 7:31 pm
I prefer fiberglass even though the aluminum is stronger... Drive past a home with 10 yr old aluminum screens and you'll see why, as WoW alluded to. I also like a half screen as I can't stand having to look outside through a screen. That is personal preference though. The bug factor is pretty irrelevant as half-screens will have a weather strip at the top.
Re: Aluminum vs. fiberglass screens
#5
Post
by jayhawk » Mon Nov 14, 7:07 am
Thanks for the feedback.
Regarding the oxidize - how common is this in those 10 year windows?
Can it be cleaned off the window? Does it come right back?
Re: Aluminum vs. fiberglass screens
#6
Post
by Windows on Washington » Mon Nov 14, 11:18 am
Very to easy to get off but comes right back. It is a ongoing condition as the oxidation never stops.
Re: Aluminum vs. fiberglass screens
#7
Post
by HomeSealed » Mon Nov 14, 11:28 am
Windows on Washington wrote:Very to easy to get off but comes right back. It is a ongoing condition as the oxidation never stops.
+1... Plus there is the fact that the screen itself looks terrible as it oxidizes.
I would say that it is very commonplace to occur before 10 years, although there are environmental variables that will play into that.
There is a reason that fg mesh has become so popular and is pretty much standard, and cost is only part of it.
Re: Aluminum vs. fiberglass screens
#8
Post
by TheWindowNerd » Mon Nov 14, 11:35 am
The company is the world’s best glass fiber window screen supplier. We are your one-stop shop for all needs. Our staff are highly-specialized and will help you find the product you need.
Depending on the mfg you may also have an option for a higher visibility screen mesh.
Lets in more light and air.
Re: Aluminum vs. fiberglass screens
#9
Post
by Windows on Washington » Mon Nov 14, 11:46 am
anthony wrote:Depending on the mfg you may also have an option for a higher visibility screen mesh.
Lets in more light and air.
+1
Most of the high visibility screen that is out there from the big guys is thin wire stainless mesh. Very nice stuff but be prepared to pay.
Re: Aluminum vs. fiberglass screens
#10
Post
by hootie » Mon Nov 14, 4:24 pm
Any idea what product Softlite uses?
Re: Aluminum vs. fiberglass screens
#12
Post
by Window4U (IL) » Mon Nov 14, 6:13 pm
hootie wrote:Any idea what product Softlite uses?
Softlite uses BetterVue™ Screens by Phifer.
Sunrise Windows use OptiView™ Screens.
Okna and Starmark use ThruVision® Screens.
All are high visibilty fabric screens that are easier to see through and provide almost a third more air flow than normal fiberglass screens.
The OptiView™ screen is the most transparent of the three in my opinion, but it is also an option you have to pay for with Sunrise. The ThruVision® and BetterVue™ screens come standard at no cost on the Softlite, Okna and Starmark products. All are an obvious improvement over regular fiberglass screens.
If you're looking for an affordable way to rescreen your home, fiberglass is the way to go. Whether you're rescreening old frames or building brand new ones, this is a great screen option for high-traffic areas in your home and around your outdoor property. Our fiberglass screen rolls come in a plethora of sizes to perfectly fit your windows and screen frames for your outdoor areas.
Get your home screened for less when you choose fiberglass screen rolls. Fiberglass is a very forgiving material that won't easily break like aluminum. Instead, when pushed in it will return to its original shape. This is ideal for areas where your pets and children frequent, like pool areas or the porch screen door. If you're building your own screen frames, buying in rolls will save you time and money. Depending on the size you choose, you may even be able to fully screen your home and property using one roll! The rolls are also excellent for professional screeners who go through screen rapidly. By stocking up on these fiberglass screen rolls for your inventory, you'll be able to offer an economical screen option to your customers. The fiberglass screen is made with a 18x16 mesh and a .011 diameter. We offer the screen in both Silver Grey and Black, both of which will look great anywhere they're installed. Choose the right roll size for your needs with the following options: 36" x 25', 48" x 25', 24" x 100', 24" x 600', 36" x 100', 36" x 600', 48" x 100', 48" x 600', 60" x 100', 72" x 100', 84" x 100', and 96" x 100'. Please note that Silver Grey is unavailable for: 36" x 25', 48" x 25', 84" x 100', and 96" x 100'.
It is available in two colors, charcoal and silver grey. The screen mesh is easy to install in window screens. It's 18x16, .011 diameter. Made in the USA.
Silver Grey unavailable for: 36x25, 48x25, 84x100, 96x100
SPLINE SIZE GUIDE
Fiberglass is a great choice for all of your general screening needs for residential and commercial use. With this screen, you'll be able to keep insects like flies out when opening a window or sitting on your patio to relax. If you have other questions about our fiberglass patio and pool screen rolls, please feel free to contact us via or at 972-438- for more information.
Are you interested in learning more about Custom Size Fiber Mesh Roll? Contact us today to secure an expert consultation!